Solution
Correct Option: (a)
The problem states that the density of the cylinder is equal to that of water ($\rho_c = \rho_w$). This implies that when the cylinder is fully submerged, the buoyant force $B$ exactly equals the gravitational force $mg$.
$$ B_{max} = \rho V g = mg $$Phase 1: Lifting inside water
While the cylinder is completely submerged (moving from depth $d$ until the top surface touches the water level), the tension $T$ in the cord is:
$$ T = mg – B_{max} = mg – mg = 0 $$Since the tension is zero, the work done by the pulling agency during this phase is zero.
Phase 2: Emerging from water
As the cylinder is pulled out, let $y$ be the length of the cylinder outside the water. The submerged length is $(l – y)$.
The buoyant force becomes: $B(y) = \rho A (l-y) g$.
The tension required to lift it slowly (equilibrium) is:
$$ T(y) = mg – B(y) = \rho A l g – \rho A (l-y) g = \rho A g y $$Here, $\rho A g$ is a constant. This shows that Tension increases linearly from $0$ (at $y=0$) to $mg$ (at $y=l$).
Calculation of Work:
The work done is the integral of tension over the displacement $l$ (or the area under the T-y graph shown above).
$$ W = \int_0^l T(y) dy = \int_0^l (\rho A g y) dy $$ $$ W = \rho A g \left[ \frac{y^2}{2} \right]_0^l = \frac{1}{2} \rho A g l^2 $$Substituting $m = \rho A l$:
$$ W = \frac{1}{2} (m) g l = 0.5 mgl $$