Thermodynamics Solution: Question 26
The system consists of a piston-cylinder arrangement containing $CO_2$.
- Initial State: $n_c$ moles of gas and $n_d$ moles of solid (dry ice) at temperature $T_c$.
- Final State: $(n_c + n_d)$ moles of gas at temperature $T$.
- Process: The external pressure is zero (vacuum). The pressure of the gas is solely responsible for balancing the weight of the piston ($Mg$). Since the piston mass and area are constant, the process is Isobaric.
Work is done by the gas as it expands against the constant pressure $P$.
$$ W = P(V_f – V_i) $$Using the Ideal Gas Law ($PV = nRT$):
- Final Volume (all gas): $V_f = \frac{(n_c + n_d)RT}{P}$
- Initial Volume (gas portion): $V_i \approx \frac{n_c R T_c}{P}$ (Neglecting the volume of the solid)
Substituting these into the work equation:
$$ W = P \left[ \frac{(n_c + n_d)RT}{P} – \frac{n_c R T_c}{P} \right] $$ $$ W = (n_c + n_d)RT – n_c R T_c $$The total change in internal energy consists of two parts: the energy required to sublimate the solid dry ice and the energy required to raise the temperature of the gases.
$$ \Delta U = \Delta U_{\text{sublimation}} + \Delta U_{\text{heating}} $$- Sublimation: $L$ is the molar specific internal energy of sublimation. $$ \Delta U_{\text{sublimation}} = n_d L $$
- Heating: We heat the total final amount of gas $(n_c + n_d)$ from the initial temperature $T_c$ to $T$. $$ \Delta U_{\text{heating}} = (n_c + n_d) C_v (T – T_c) $$
Combining these:
$$ \Delta U = n_d L + (n_c + n_d) C_v (T – T_c) $$$$ Q = \Delta U + W $$
Substituting the expressions derived in steps 2 and 3:
$$ Q = \left[ n_d L + (n_c + n_d)C_v(T – T_c) \right] + \left[ (n_c + n_d)RT – n_c R T_c \right] $$To simplify, we rearrange the Work term to match the temperature difference format. Note that $(n_c+n_d)RT – n_c RT_c$ can be rewritten as:
$$ W = (n_c + n_d)R(T – T_c) + n_d R T_c $$Now substituting this back into the heat equation:
$$ Q = n_d L + (n_c + n_d)C_v(T – T_c) + (n_c + n_d)R(T – T_c) + n_d R T_c $$Grouping the terms with $(T – T_c)$ and using Mayer’s Relation ($C_p = C_v + R$):
$$ Q = n_d L + (n_c + n_d)(C_v + R)(T – T_c) + n_d R T_c $$Rearrange the equation to isolate $T$:
$$ (n_c + n_d) C_p (T – T_c) = Q – n_d L – n_d R T_c $$Expanding the Left Hand Side:
$$ (n_c + n_d) C_p T – (n_c + n_d) C_p T_c = Q – n_d L – n_d R T_c $$ $$ (n_c + n_d) C_p T = Q – n_d L – n_d R T_c + n_c C_p T_c + n_d C_p T_c $$Grouping the $T_c$ terms:
$$ (n_c + n_d) C_p T = Q – n_d L + n_c C_p T_c + n_d (C_p – R) T_c $$Since $C_p – R = C_v$:
$$ (n_c + n_d) C_p T = Q – n_d L + n_c C_p T_c + n_d C_v T_c $$Substituting values for $CO_2$:
$CO_2$ is a linear polyatomic molecule ($f=5$, ignoring vibrational modes at low temp).
Substituting these values:
$$ (n_c + n_d) \left(\frac{7}{2}R\right) T = Q – n_d L + n_c \left(\frac{7}{2}R\right) T_c + n_d \left(\frac{5}{2}R\right) T_c $$Multiply by 2 to remove fractions:
$$ 7(n_c + n_d) R T = 2Q – 2n_d L + 7n_c R T_c + 5n_d R T_c $$ $$ 7(n_c + n_d) R T = 2Q – 2n_d L + (7n_c + 5n_d) R T_c $$Final Expression:
