*GRAVITATION CYU 7

Physics Solution – Question 7

Solution to Rotating Earth Disc Problem

Model Description

We model the Earth as a flat disc of uniform thickness $h$ and density $\rho$. The disc rotates with angular velocity $\omega$ about a vertical axis passing through its center (North Pole).

  • North Pole: Center of the disc ($r=0$).
  • South Pole: Circular edge ($r=R$).
  • Longitudes: Radial lines extending from the center.
  • Latitudes: Concentric circles centered at the pole.
  • East: Tangential direction along the rotation.
ω Longitude Latitude N h

Part (a): Thickness of the Disc

We are given that the radius of the disc is very large ($R \to \infty$) compared to the distance from the surface. At the center (North Pole), the gravitational field is equivalent to that near an infinite sheet of uniform mass density $\rho$ and thickness $h$.

The surface mass density is $\sigma = \rho h$. The gravitational field due to an infinite sheet is given by: $$ g_0 = 2\pi G \sigma = 2\pi G (\rho h) $$

Solving for thickness $h$:

$$ h = \frac{g_0}{2\pi \rho G} $$

Part (b): Firing along a Longitude

A shell is fired with velocity $u$ at an angle $\theta$ with the longitude. This means the projection of the velocity on the horizontal plane is along the radial line.

Correction to Answer Key: The provided answer key suggests a linear dependence on time, which is physically incorrect for Coriolis deflection in this geometry. The deviation arises due to the Coriolis force (or conservation of angular momentum), which results in a deflection proportional to $t^2$. The correct derivation follows.

1. Analysis in Rotating Frame (Coriolis Effect)

Let the firing point be the origin of a local coordinate frame rotating with the disc.

  • $\hat{i}$ (x-axis): Radial direction (along Longitude).
  • $\hat{j}$ (y-axis): Tangential direction (East).
  • $\hat{k}$ (z-axis): Vertical direction.
The angular velocity vector is $\vec{\omega} = \omega \hat{k}$.
The initial velocity vector is $\vec{v} = u \cos\theta \hat{i} + u \sin\theta \hat{k}$.

The Coriolis acceleration is given by $\vec{a}_{cor} = -2\vec{\omega} \times \vec{v}$. $$ \vec{a}_{cor} = -2(\omega \hat{k}) \times (u \cos\theta \hat{i} + u \sin\theta \hat{k}) $$ Since $\hat{k} \times \hat{k} = 0$ and $\hat{k} \times \hat{i} = \hat{j}$: $$ \vec{a}_{cor} = -2\omega u \cos\theta \hat{j} $$

The acceleration is in the $-\hat{j}$ direction (West). The displacement (deflection) $d$ is: $$ d = \left| \frac{1}{2} a_{cor} t^2 \right| = \omega u \cos\theta t^2 $$

2. Time of Flight

For the vertical motion, assuming gravity $g$ is constant: $$ t = \frac{2 u_z}{g} = \frac{2 u \sin\theta}{g} $$

3. Final Deflection

Substituting $t$ into the deflection equation:

$$ d = \omega u \cos\theta \left( \frac{2 u \sin\theta}{g} \right)^2 = \frac{4 \omega u^3 \sin^2\theta \cos\theta}{g^2} $$

The direction is West (to the right of the direction of motion relative to the ground).

Start Longitude Actual Path Deflection (West) N (In) E W

Part (c): Firing along a Latitude

The shell is fired with velocity $u$ at an angle $\theta$ with the latitude. This means the horizontal component of velocity is along the East-West direction.

Velocity Components:
Radial velocity $v_r = 0$.
Tangential velocity $v_{tan} = u \cos\theta$ (Eastward).
Vertical velocity $v_z = u \sin\theta$.

1. Effective Radial Force

The particle experiences a change in the required centripetal force and the Coriolis force. Both act in the radial direction.
Coriolis Acceleration: $\vec{a}_{cor} = -2\vec{\omega} \times \vec{v}$. $$ \vec{a}_{cor} = -2(\omega \hat{k}) \times (u \cos\theta \hat{j}) $$ Since $\hat{k} \times \hat{j} = -\hat{i}$ (where $\hat{i}$ is radial outward): $$ \vec{a}_{cor} = 2\omega u \cos\theta \hat{i} $$

This acceleration is directed radially outward (South).

2. Deflection Calculation

Using the same time of flight $t = \frac{2 u \sin\theta}{g}$, the radial deflection is: $$ d = \frac{1}{2} a_{cor} t^2 = \frac{1}{2} (2\omega u \cos\theta) \left( \frac{2 u \sin\theta}{g} \right)^2 $$ $$ d = \omega u \cos\theta \frac{4 u^2 \sin^2\theta}{g^2} $$

The “$\pm$” in the original answer key corresponds to firing East (+) or West (-). If fired West, the Coriolis force directs inward.

Result: $\displaystyle \frac{4 \omega u^3 \sin^2\theta \cos\theta}{g^2}$ away from the latitude.

Start Latitude (East) Path (Outward) Deflection (South)