NLM O21

Question 21 | Which Block Slides First?
JEE Physics · Friction

Which Block Starts Sliding First?

Two identical blocks share the same friction limit. The answer therefore depends only on which block receives the larger horizontal normal reaction from the rod.

Answer: (b) Block B
1

Identify the two contact forces

Let \(R_A\) and \(R_B\) denote the magnitudes of the horizontal normal forces exerted by the rod on blocks A and B, respectively.

Rod between blocks A and B A force F pulls the top of the vertical rod to the right. The rod pushes block A leftward with force R A and block B rightward with the larger force R B. A B F RA RB rough horizontal floor
Forces exerted by the rod on the blocks. Arrow lengths emphasize \(R_B > R_A\).
2

Compare the normal reactions

Rightward on rod: \(F\) Rightward on rod: \(R_A\) Leftward on rod: \(R_B\)

The force is increased gradually, so before any slipping begins the rod is in horizontal equilibrium. Hence,

\[ F+R_A-R_B=0 \]
\[ \boxed{R_B=R_A+F} \]

Since \(F>0\), the normal reaction on block B is necessarily greater than the normal reaction on block A.

On block B \(R_B\)
>
On block A \(R_A\)
3

Compare with limiting friction

The contacts with the rod are horizontal, so the vertical normal reaction from the floor is \(mg\) for each block. Because the blocks and their contact with the floor are identical, their maximum static frictions are equal.

Block A

Required friction: \(f_A=R_A\)

Maximum available: \(f_{A,\max}=\mu_s mg\)

Block B

Required friction: \(f_B=R_B\)

Maximum available: \(f_{B,\max}=\mu_s mg\)

Both blocks have the same friction ceiling, but block B has the larger friction demand. Therefore B reaches limiting friction first as \(F\) increases.

At the instant B is about to move

\(R_B=\mu_s mg\), whereas \(R_A=R_B-F<\mu_s mg\). Thus A can still remain at rest when B is on the verge of sliding.

Final answer (b) Block B starts sliding first.