Physics Problem: Stepped Cylinder Oscillation
Question 10
A vertical tube has two portions of cross-sectional areas $A_1$ and $A_2$ ($A_2 > A_1$). Two pistons are connected by a light rod and can slide in these portions without friction. The total mass of the assembly is $m$. Between the pistons, $n$ moles of an ideal gas are trapped at temperature $T$. Atmospheric pressure is $p_0$. If the assembly is shifted slightly from equilibrium and released, find the angular frequency of oscillation (assuming isothermal conditions).
Solution
Consider the forces acting on the entire piston-rod assembly.
Downward Forces:
1. Gravity: $mg$
2. Atmospheric pressure on top piston: $p_0 A_2$
3. Gas pressure on bottom piston: $P A_1$ (acts downwards because gas is above it)
Upward Forces:
1. Atmospheric pressure on bottom piston: $p_0 A_1$
2. Gas pressure on top piston: $P A_2$ (acts upwards because gas is below it)
Net Equilibrium Equation:
Total Upward Force = Total Downward Force
$$ P A_2 + p_0 A_1 = P A_1 + p_0 A_2 + mg $$
Grouping terms by pressure:
$$ P(A_2 – A_1) = p_0(A_2 – A_1) + mg $$
Let the assembly be displaced downwards by a small distance $x$.
The upper piston moves down into the gas (Volume decreases by $A_2 x$).
The lower piston moves down out of the gas (Volume increases by $A_1 x$).
Net Volume Change:
$$ dV = -A_2 x + A_1 x = -(A_2 – A_1)x $$
Assuming an Isothermal Process ($PV = \text{const}$):
$$ dP = – \frac{P dV}{V} = – \frac{P [-(A_2 – A_1)x]}{V} = \frac{P(A_2 – A_1)x}{V} $$
The restoring force is the change in the net upward gas force. The net gas force is $F_{gas} = P(A_2 – A_1)$.
$$ F_{restoring} = – dP(A_2 – A_1) $$
$$ F_{restoring} = – \left[ \frac{P(A_2 – A_1)x}{V} \right] (A_2 – A_1) $$
$$ F_{restoring} = – \frac{P(A_2 – A_1)^2}{V} x $$
The effective spring constant is $k = \frac{P(A_2 – A_1)^2}{V}$. $$ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{k}{m}} = \sqrt{\frac{P(A_2 – A_1)^2}{mV}} $$ From the Ideal Gas Law, $V = \frac{nRT}{P}$. Substitute this into the equation: $$ \omega = \sqrt{\frac{P(A_2 – A_1)^2}{m (nRT/P)}} = \sqrt{\frac{P^2 (A_2 – A_1)^2}{m nRT}} $$ $$ \omega = \frac{P(A_2 – A_1)}{\sqrt{m n R T}} $$ Finally, substitute the equilibrium condition $P(A_2 – A_1) = p_0(A_2 – A_1) + mg$ into the numerator: $$ \omega = \frac{p_0(A_2 – A_1) + mg}{\sqrt{n m R T}} $$
